by edatoakrun (Posted Fri, 24 Feb 2017 15:30:36 GMT+7)
wwhitney wrote:...That would drop the breakeven distance in terms of charging time to 533 miles. That's still over 8 hours of driving at 65 mph. With charging time, that's longer than most anyone would want to drive either car in one day.
So the conclusion still holds that the Ioniq EV's greater efficiency can't make up for its smaller battery, in terms of time spent charging on a long trip.
Cheers, Wayne
No, using your assumptions of the Ioniq's efficiency advantage (which, BTW are are almost certainly too high for a speed as low as ~65 mph, but probably close to correct for a trip at ~80 mph)
the Ioniq would complete any trip over 533 miles in less time than the Bolt.TonyWilliams wrote:edatoakrun wrote:Tony,
You still don't seem to understand the simple fact that a BEV that gets superior efficiency in m/kWh from the charge site will spend less time charging for each mile driven.
I'll try one more time to explain the facts to you.
...If your answer is just better consumption rate with equal charge rate, then sure, the other cars win by a small margin. But, I'd have to see those other cars actually add 125 miles of range AT AN AVERAGE RATE OF 42KW.
That's what you have to beat:
![Image]()
Actually Tony, if you want to add the Ioniq to that chart, you would want to specify ~ 75 to ~100 miles between recharges, which reportedly would allow close to a ~42 kW charge rate over the entire trip.
You will then see the total travel time line for the Bolt cross (exceed) the Ioniq's on your chart, exactly where depending on your assumptions of actual efficiency at speed for both BEVs.
You two are welcome to continue arguing over which of these two BEVs can make any trip of eight to fifteen hours a few minutes faster than the other under any
realistic assumptions, or even the distinctly
unreal assumptions Tony prefers to consider, as graphically displayed above.
You'd have to be an idiot, IMO, to consider that small a travel time advantage by either BEV a significant reason to choose to buy either of them, when any
beater ICEV would shorten total travel time on the same route by hours.